Figure - Koch Postulates Flow

Purpose

Show classical causality steps and where modern molecular diagnostics break or extend them.

Used In

Diagram

flowchart TD
  A[1. Associate<br/>Found in diseased hosts] --> B[2. Isolate<br/>Pure culture]
  B --> C[3. Inoculate<br/>Reproduce disease in host]
  C --> D[4. Re-isolate<br/>Same microbe again]
  D --> E[Causal link accepted]

  A -. exception .-> X1[Asymptomatic carriers]
  B -. exception .-> X2[Unculturable organisms]
  C -. exception .-> X3[Ethics / no animal model]
  A -. modern .-> M1[PCR / WGS detect DNA ≠ prove disease]
  B -. modern .-> M2[Molecular Koch: knock out virulence gene]

Teaching Legend

StepClassical toolModern analogue
AssociateMicroscopy / pathologyNAAT, metagenomics
IsolateCulture and IsolationSometimes impossible → genes/markers
CausationAnimal challengeGene knockout / gain-of-function evidence
ConfirmRe-cultureSequence identity / phylogeny

Quick Self-Check

  1. Which postulate fails for viruses that cannot be cultured in cell-free media historically?
  2. Why can a PCR+ nasal swab fail postulate-style causation?